Home | Members | Help | Submission Rules | Log In |
Recently Added | Categories | Titles | Completed Fics | Random Fic | Search | Top Fictions

Reviews for Phantom of Hogwarts

bluemooonie2015.05.04 - 01:46PM50: 48- Fathers and Sons, Part 1Signed
Really like the discussion of personality and character here from hermione :)

Author's Response: Yay! I'm glad you enjoyed it. Thank you so much for reviewing! :)

Jane3332014.05.29 - 06:56AM50: 48- Fathers and Sons, Part 1Signed
Oh god, and now presumably in the next chapter she's going to sing Christine's sorrowful song about her father...! After all this sad, painful talk about fathers...oh god, I might cry... Beautifully plotted out!

Author's Response: *blush* Aww, thank you! You just made emy morning brighter. Thanks so much for reviewing! :)

Drinking chocolate2010.12.07 - 04:20PM50: 48- Fathers and Sons, Part 1Signed
Funny how we can tell you wrote this pre-DH because, even though you are spot-on with your canon portrayals as usual, you give James a little and Dumbledore a LOT more credit than they ended up deserving, from JKR's portrayal! Ha. I wonder if they even got a single detention for the Prank. I am really happy for Snape in this chapter because his discomfort over Hermione's grief on his behalf is exactly the same as what a normal, healthy adult goes through when falling in love, not something compromised or celibate or inferior because he's Snape and must always be deprived. He wouldn't be familiar with this sympathy, of course; Albus, er, JKR, usually reserved Fawkes' phoenix tears for others! But even in DH canon, Hermione is the one to weep for others and offer them that healing. I'm glad she gets to do this here.

Author's Response: *beams* This was another chance for me to come up with a plausible backstory based on the snippets in canon, and I'm so glad you liked the way it played out. I'm also glad that we Snapefen understand that Severus deserves to heal, even if JKR didn't. Thanks so much for reviewing! :)

phantomofhogwarts2009.03.30 - 12:15PM50: 48- Fathers and Sons, Part 1Signed
I love how they progress every time they meet! I know this isn't a long review as usual, but I am following instructions and immediatly proceeding to part 2! ^_~

Author's Response: LOL Good for you! ;) Thanks for reviewing! :)

ElectricBloo2008.03.16 - 06:42PM50: 48- Fathers and Sons, Part 1Signed
Good goth, how did such a fabulous chapter end up with only five reviews? Shame on us readers. What a wonderfully cathartic experience you created, cheers for posting.

Author's Response: LOL That's okay, I daresay it's because they were so intent on following my instructions to proceed directly to part two. *snerk* But thank you, for your kind words and for reviewing! :)

Guinnevere2006.09.07 - 05:27AM50: 48- Fathers and Sons, Part 1Signed
Fab. Just fab. I love the memory sequence, and how he trusts her with it. And, of course, if anything can convince Severus that he's misjudged Harry, it would be the fact that he kept his word about not revealing That Memory. Good job.

Author's Response: *beams* The "Snape's history" and the "life debt scene" were some things I worked the hardest on to make believeable, so I'm SO pleased you liked them. *whew!* :)

lpf2006.08.14 - 02:14PM50: 48- Fathers and Sons, Part 1Signed
I am proceeding directly to part two, but I noticed that this chapter only had 3 reviews when it deserves so many more. Great job so far, I can't wait for the rest!

Author's Response: *blush* Why thank you! I appreciate the thought, indeed. *huge smile* Hope you keep enjoying it! And thanks as always for reviewing! :)

Moonlit River2006.05.05 - 09:57PM50: 48- Fathers and Sons, Part 1Signed
*applauds*
I love it so far!
Thanks SOOO much for the update!
^^-

Moonie

Author's Response: *curtsies* You're quite welcome. I'm glad you're still enjoying it. *beams* Thanks as always for reviewing! :)


[Previous] 1 2 [Next]


Disclaimers
Terms of Use
Credits

Ashwinder
A Severus Snape/Hermione Granger archive in the Harry Potter universe

Copyright © 2003-2019 Sycophant Hex
All rights reserved