Home | Members | Help | Submission Rules | Log In |
Recently Added | Categories | Titles | Completed Fics | Random Fic | Search | Top Fictions

Reviews for Phantom of Hogwarts

Jane3332014.05.21 - 05:09AM11: 11- Surprises at the First Rehearsal *part one*Signed
I'm LOVING how the relationships between Hermione, Snape and Harry are parallel with their parts in the musical! And how Hermione and Snape's reactions to each other are precisely those between Christine and the Phantom - the mesmeric connection, the sexual tension, the way they seem to hypnotise each other. And my god, Snape IS the Phantom! And what an inspired use of the Sonorous charm - it fits the music perfectly! I am so glad that you were the person to make this quirky idea into a story - it could so easily have been a disaster, but you've pulled it off with great aplomb! Seriously impressed!

Author's Response: Oh, wow! I'm blushing over here. I'm so glad you're enjoying it still. Thank you so much for such a lovely review that just made my morning! :)

magicalpresence2012.01.10 - 08:47PM11: 11- Surprises at the First Rehearsal *part one*Signed
Still going strong without knowing *anything* about Phantom of the Opera! (The guylian chocolates have been abandoned, but are looking at me sadly)

Author's Response: LOL Well, at this point, I would hope that you DO know about Phantom of the Opera, considering how much detail I keep putting in of the songs and dialogue. ;P Wait, who's looking at whom sadly now? The chocolates are looking at you or you are looking at the chocolates? *snerk* Thanks for reviewing! :)

Drinking chocolate2010.11.16 - 04:15PM11: 11- Surprises at the First Rehearsal *part one*Signed
I'm loving the work you're doing with chairs and body language in this story! I first noticed it with Seamus and Dean, when you had them tilt on the back legs of their chairs a few chapters ago until Snape glared at them. Here, I see the way you have Snape sitting with his limbs folded up or gesticulating with his performance(s) and it's a fantastic way to capture his combination of immature boyishness, smirky pride, defensiveness and dignity. And I love Draco's Italian accent. I guess he goes to the wizarding tailors in Milan for his dress robes. :-)

Author's Response: Oh, body language, voice inflection, and facial expression are all VERY important to me. It's all about metacommunication, baby! :D Glad you're still enjoying it. Thanks for such a lovely review! :)

Onexandxonly072010.07.11 - 11:40AM11: 11- Surprises at the First Rehearsal *part one*Signed
I just really got into fanfic recently and found your story as I have only begun I have to say i LOVE the story so far! as I havent read the second part of this chapter yet (doing so after my review!) I just wanted to say that this Chapter was amazing the intense of the first reading gave me chills! the way both Hermione and Snape seemed drawn to their parts and to eachother Im really LOVEING this sroty!

Author's Response: *beams* Welcome, new reader! I'm glad you're enjoying it. I hope you like the rest (and it's very long, LOL). Thanks so much for reviewing! :)

BulletTimeScully2009.08.06 - 01:55AM11: 11- Surprises at the First Rehearsal *part one*Signed
Oh. My. God. **falls into musically induced coma!!!** The interaction between Hermione and Severus in this scene was absolutely amazing! PotO is my favorite musical of all time (sadly I have yet to see it live) but this chapter brought it to life! I played my soundtrack at the parts where they sing. The music gives me goosebumps anyway, but imagining Hermione and Severus **Alan Rickman...gasp** singing so passionately to each other.....I shivered! Seriously! Wonderful wonderful story! I cannot wait to read more!

Author's Response: *beams and bounces* Yay! I'm glad you've enjoyed it! Thanks so much for reviewing! :)

phantomofhogwarts2009.03.23 - 05:11PM11: 11- Surprises at the First Rehearsal *part one*Signed
*Squee!* I love Hermione and Severus's reactions to each others' voices! You write so well, I love it!! It's like they know exactly what should be felt in response to the songs and to each other, as the Phantom and Christine of course, but also as themselves!

Author's Response: *beams* I just think of how Michael Crawford's voice affects me when I listen to the PotO soundtrack, and I think of Alan Rickman's dreamy voice, and it all just comes out! LOL Thanks so much for reviewing! :)

DistinctVagueness2008.05.28 - 09:33PM11: 11- Surprises at the First Rehearsal *part one*Signed
This chapter is just as fantastic as I remember it. I'm listening to the PotO soundtrack as I re-read and you're excellently setting the scene with this rehearsal chapter. Lovely!

Author's Response: *blush* Thank you! I'm glad it holds up on a re-read. :)

ElectricBloo2008.03.08 - 09:12PM11: 11- Surprises at the First Rehearsal *part one*Signed
Towards the end of this chapter I couldn't help but feel the beginnings of bitterness towards AD in respect of his treatment of SS. Cheers for posting.

Author's Response: Ah, I hoped that the seeds I planted all along the way would have borne plausible fruit when all hell breaks loose later. Thanks for reviewing! :)

[Previous] 1 2 3 [Next]


Disclaimers
Terms of Use
Credits

Ashwinder
A Severus Snape/Hermione Granger archive in the Harry Potter universe

Copyright © 2003-2019 Sycophant Hex
All rights reserved